This higher-tier question focuses on reasoning rather than calculation. You must explain why two nearby numbers round to different tens, showing a full understanding of place value and midpoint logic.
Exam tip: In ‘Explain why’ questions, refer to the midpoint value and which side each number lies on. This reasoning gains full method marks even without long calculations.
Try more: 184 vs 188; 1,249 vs 1,252; 345.4 vs 349.6.
This higher-tier GCSE Maths question moves beyond simple rounding and asks you to explain why two close numbers can round to different tens. Understanding the logic behind rounding demonstrates mastery of place value reasoning, not just memorising the 5-and-above rule. When two numbers lie on opposite sides of a midpoint (in this case, 255), they round to different multiples of ten because each is closer to a different end of the interval.
When rounding to the nearest ten, every block of ten has a midpoint that determines where the cut-off occurs. For the interval from 250 to 260, the midpoint is 255. Any number below 255 rounds down to 250; any number 255 or above rounds up to 260. Recognising that rounding is about distance from this midpoint is crucial for success in higher-tier reasoning questions.
Example 1. Compare 184 and 188 when rounding to the nearest ten.
Example 2. Compare 372.4 and 374.9.
Example 3. 253.79 vs 257.11.
Explaining why values round differently is not just theoretical. In finance, reporting £253.79 as £250 and £257.11 as £260 helps communicate that small differences can change an estimate category. In engineering, small measurement differences affect which specification a component fits into. In computing, data is often grouped by tens or hundreds; understanding rounding boundaries ensures consistency in summaries or database grouping.
Q1: What exactly causes two numbers so close together to round differently?
A: Each is on a different side of the rounding midpoint. 255 divides the interval between 250 and 260; numbers below it round down, numbers above it round up.
Q2: If a number is exactly 255, which way should I round?
A: By convention, numbers ending exactly in 5 round up, so 255 → 260.
Q3: Does the decimal part affect rounding to tens?
A: Only if the decimal changes the ones digit after rounding. The rule still focuses on the ones digit.
When asked to explain a rounding result, always refer to the midpoint and relative distance. Sketch a quick number line: mark the two endpoints and the midpoint. Then show which side each number lies on. This visual reasoning earns full marks in “Explain why…” questions and prepares you for bounds and estimation topics later in the GCSE Maths course.